Banning Laptops in Class
August 14, 2008 by Kathy McManus
“Could you repeat the question?”
That’s the most common response law professor David Cole gets when he calls on disengaged students during class at Georgetown University. The question, Cole says, “is usually asked while the student glances up from the laptop screen that otherwise occupies his or her field of vision.”
The laptop--the favorite in-class tool for college and university students across the country—is coming unplugged.
When used responsibly—for taking notes or quickly accessing research—a laptop provides valuable educational support. But when used irresponsibly—for watching YouTube, surfing the web, emailing, IM-ing, playing games, checking sports scores, and shopping for shoes instead of engaging in class — laptops become the scourge of professors, some of whom are now banning them.
“I was happy to compete with Minesweeper and solitaire,” said University of Michigan law professor Don Herzog, but not “the entire internet.” Herzog banned all laptops from his classes for a day, and was so “stunned by how much better the class was,” that he has vowed to make the embargo permanent in the fall.
Professor Herzog is not alone in his class action. At Harvard, Yale, and Columbia, professors have nixed classroom laptops as well. At the University of Chicago Law School, classroom Wi-Fi was recently cut in response to an “epidemic” of web browsing. And at UCLA School of Law, when the meandering minds of the country’s future lawyers need to be jolted back from cyberspace to the Socratic method, professors can activate a “kill switch” to disable classroom Wi-Fi.
Many students disdain their professors’ attempts at online mind control, saying if classes weren’t so boring, they wouldn’t look for so many distractions. Ann Althouse, a professor from the University of Wisconsin Law School agrees with the students. “The idea that we’re going to somehow save these students from being distracted is a bit absurd,” she said. “Especially in law school, I’m on the side of individual responsibility and freedom.”
Tell us what you think: Should students be busted down for booting up in class? Should professors be responsible for making lectures and classes interesting enough to hold students’ attention? Do students have a responsibility to pay attention?
Find More ///
- in Education, Science & Technology
- in Blog
- about schools, teachers
56 Comments
What do you think? Leave a comment
August 16, 2008 by Sally G
Reply
April 21, 2010 by mariam
yoru song wasok but sad
Reply
September 17, 2010 by Precious
ok.....
August 17, 2008 by Suanne G
Reply
August 20, 2008 by Thomas hutegger
Reply
August 21, 2008 by Sally G
Reply
August 23, 2008 by Anne K
Reply
August 24, 2008 by Melissa S
Reply
September 19, 2008 by Kay Brown
Reply
August 26, 2008 by Heather Myers
Reply
September 2, 2008 by animal_lover
Reply
September 12, 2008 by Raymond Kelly McElhiney II
Reply
September 18, 2008 by Stephen Hinkle
Reply
October 8, 2008 by Mara
Reply
October 9, 2008 by Noel Jefferson
Reply
1 2 3 4 5 »
Tell us what you think.
Let the world know what you think, but please do so responsibly. Comments are moderated and we will not post personal attacks, obscene language or inappropriate material, comments with links, or comments from people under the age of 18. If you have a question, check out our Comment Submission Guidelines.